| ICE16 | UMF STJARNAN GARĐABÆR | |||||||||||
| season | cup | round | opponents | result | scorers | result | scorers | |||||
| 14-15 | E3 | P1 | Bangor City FC | H | 4-0 | Ó.K.Finsen (2), V.P.Gunnarsson, A.M.Björgvinsson | A | 4-0 | M.Rauschenberg, A.M.Björgvinsson (2), A.Jóhannson | |||
| P2 | Motherwell FC | A | 2-2 | Ó.K.Finsen (2) | H | 3-2 | * | Ó.K.Finsen, R.Toft, A.Jóhannson | ||||
| P3 | KKS Lech Poznań SA | H | 1-0 | R.Toft | A | 0-0 | ||||||
| P4 | FC Internazionale Milano | H | 0-3 | A | 0-6 | |||||||
| 15-16 | E1 | P2 | Celtic FC Glasgow | A | 0-2 | H | 1-4 | Ó.K.Finsen | ||||
| 17-18 | E3 | P1 | Shamrock Rovers FC Dublin | H | 0-1 | A | 0-1 | |||||
| 18-19 | E3 | Q1 | Nõmme Kalju FC Tallinn | H | 3-0 | H.Halldórsson, B.Sigurðsson, G.Baldvinsson | A | 0-1 | ||||
| Q2 | FC København | H | 0-2 | A | 0-5 | |||||||
| 19-20 | E3 | Q1 | Tallinna FCI Levadia | H | 2-1 | Þ.M.Ragnarsson (2) | A | 2-3 | *^ | Þ.M.Ragnarsson, B.Guðjonsson | ||
| Q2 | RCD Espanyol Barcelona | A | 0-4 | H | 1-2 | B.Sigurðsson | ||||||
| 21-22 | E4 | Q1 | Bohemians FC Dublin | H | 1-1 | E.Atlason | A | 0-3 | ||||
| 24-25 | E4 | Q1 | LINFIELD FC BELFAST | H | 2-0 | A | 2-3 | |||||
| Q2 | PAIDE LINNAMEESKOND | H | 2-1 | A | 2-4 | |||||||